
State Farm® Insurance Agent Garrett Schafer
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Matthew Watson
August 14, 2025
"Caitie, Brendan, Chase, and Kirby are awesome. Knowledgeable for any needs and service is always fast! Cannot recommend them more. Customer service is impeccable!"
Tammy Welles
August 12, 2025
"Garrett, Catie and team are awesome to work with. Very responsive and always answer questions and super helpful!"
Wayne Roddy
August 12, 2025
"Caitie has always been super nice when I make my payment very professional you can always since shes glad to jear from you when you call"
Abi B
July 29, 2025
"Great customer services and helpful. I really appreciate them"
Robbie Wagnon
July 29, 2025
"I had been w/another provider for over 30 yrs. when suddenly, they were bought by a very large & commercial insurance company. Though many things changed, the main thing was that my premium almost doubled. I researched other options & found Garrett Schaffer/State Farm office to be a good fit. Though I have dealt w/Garrett, & he is sooo helpful, knowledgeable, professional and amiable, Caitie Yoes is primarily my contact w/whom I pay my premium. Caitie is very helpful, pleasant & professional. I find this warm, yet professional office demeanor is very refreshing & encouraging. The above-mentioned attributes contribute to efficient, pleasant, & fruitful business communication. If you need such products & services, I highly recommend Garrett Schaffer & Caitie Yoes to you."
loni scott
July 23, 2025
"Caitie was a very helpful, nice, and knowledgeable representative. She knew who I was each time I called, and assisted me in a timely manner. I like her spirit. She gets a 10/10!!!"
Alison Pesqueira
July 8, 2025
"Caitie Yoes was very knowledgable and a pleasure to work with today in securing a renter's liability insurance policy for my son. I highly recommend working with her!"
Chapman Bryant
July 1, 2025
"Brendan was a pleasure to work with and got me all set up very efficiently."
Elizabeth Harrah
June 10, 2025
"Having insured four teenage drivers through the years and spent many calls with the wonderful staff about issues, we've always had pleasant experiences. We've been provided with suggestions to take classes to lower our rates across all of our drivers and as our children married and moved. And even though one of our children was in the process of moving out of state and was in an accident, Caitie Yoes took the time to assist her while she obtained an agent in a different state. The customer service has always been exceptional going back to the day we initiated our policy and the moment we made home improvements when both Garrett and former employee Jake made home visits to ensure our home was adequately insured. In my 40 years of being insured as an adult, I am most satisfied with this specific agency from Caitie, Chase, Brendan, and the brief conversations I have had with Claudia. I am sure I will have the same with any other staff member of Garrett's team. I highly recommend State Farm as long as they are a reflection of the service of Garrett Schafer's Agency. If you have teenage driver's, rest easy, they will hold your hand and be there for them from day one. Since each policy is individual, it is a jumpstart for 'adulting.' When they leave the nest, they take, not only the policy, but State Farm, Garrett, and his team who will be there to help them if they breakdown in the middle of nowhere."
Juan Sarabia
June 2, 2025
"I was filling out car insurance applications on Facebook and State farm was one of them. Kevin gave me a call and after answering a few easy questions I had a few policies to choose from. I was insured in about 30 mins. Hey Garrett, this man Kevin also got me life insurance! Garrett Schafer has a great team and you should give them a call"
Ben Hollon
May 29, 2025
"Caitie is a very professional, knowledgeable, amiable, respectful, and quickly responsive to our needs, situation, emergencies, and our family coverage of State Farm products and services! Caitie will go beyond the call of duty to help our family! Caitie has always made herself available to make sure our family needs and concerns have been met! We had a situation where the other driver was at fault, and we needed to file a claim with his insurance company. Caitie researched for his insurance company name and contact information, confirmed that he was actually covered, and forward all this to us to get the claim started with the other driver's insurance company. Thank you, Caitie, for the excellent customer service that you have always provided our family. Caitie is Extraordinary Customer Service Manager and gets a 5 STAR rating from our family!!"
Jaylan Scott
May 27, 2025
"Never thought I’d leave a review for an insurance company but customer service is always perfect. Anytime I have ever asked for anything they respond way more promptly than you could even imagine."
Alex Harrah
May 21, 2025
"Caitie was so kind and helpful for me! I had just moved, and got rear-ended. She helped explain and help me with the process the entire time."
Lauren Pritchard
May 21, 2025
"I recently had to file a claim and Catie was so helpful. She works fast, always answers the phone, and goes above and beyond. She even coordinated me leaving my rental car at the repair shop so I could pick up my car without having to tag team with someone! She thinks of everything! This branch is the best state farm I have worked with!"
yuli cuenca
May 13, 2025
"Claudia Cabanillas took care of us! Super helpful and professional. Thank you!"
William Joy
May 7, 2025
"Caitie and all of the staff are friendly, professional and prompt in answering all of my questions and helpful in finding savings on all of our home and auto policies."
Jim Lawson
April 3, 2025
"I called yesterday and spoke with Kevin Terry and he helped me out so much.He even stayed on the phone while I canceled my other insurance. People like Kevin make getting something new more easier to understand. Thank you"
"Thank you so much for the kind words, Jim. We are so happy Kevin was able to provide you with such exceptional service. Thank you for choosing our agency."
C. Joy
March 31, 2025
"Garrett’s team has been very helpful and consistently responsive. I have added 2 new cars and replaced a car within our policy. Each time they’ve made the process very easy for me. Caitie and Brendan both took time to research the best policies for us, explain details, and answer all questions. I would recommend to anyone! Polite, timely, knowledgeable and professional."
"Thank you for the kind words, C. We are very happy to hear that our team was able to provide you with such timely and professional service. Thank you for choosing our agency."
Sean (Srini)
March 27, 2025
"I always had great experience with State farm. However the costs have gone up and I was shopping around even though I have a current policy with them. Caitie at Garret Schafer’s office sealed the deal, and allowed me stay with State farm. She helped me find ways to bring my costs down, close to those other popular insurance companies. She is knowledgeable, patient and hardworking. I highly recommend giving Caitie a call!"
"Srini, Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! 😊 We're thrilled to hear that Caitie was able to help you find ways to reduce your costs while keeping you with State Farm. She truly works hard to ensure our customers get the best value and service. We appreciate your recommendation and are always here to help whenever you need it!"
Kyle Matlock (That Broke Car Guy)
March 25, 2025
"Justin helped me out with a situation I had recently and was a great help. My car has the engine pulled out and I didnt want to pay insurance on that car while it isn’t running. He helped me out with getting in touch with my local government to cancel my registration so that they could pause my insurance until I get the motor reinstalled. It took me all of 5 minutes to get the process set up so I could start saving $100/mo on my insurance."
"Kyle, Wow, we're so glad Justin was able to assist you in navigating your situation and saving you money on your insurance. He truly goes the extra mile to help our customers! If you ever need anything else, we’re always here for you."
Stephen Johnson
March 21, 2025
"Katie helped me so much. She even helped me find discounts.Very impressive!"
"Stephen, Thank you for your wonderful feedback! 😊 We're so glad to hear that Katie was able to help you find discounts and make your experience even better. She truly goes above and beyond for our customers! If you ever need anything else, we’re here to help."
Todd Kirkland
March 21, 2025
"Garrett Schafer was very helpful and was able to get me a better rate than I am currently paying. Garrett was extremely attentive to my needs and he made me very happy to join the State Farm Family. I would advise anyone to use Garrett, best rates for my two cars and renters insurance policy. Thank you for everything."
"Todd, Thank you so much for your kind words! 😊 We're thrilled to hear that Garrett was able to get you a better rate and provide excellent service. It's great to know you're happy to be part of the State Farm family! We truly appreciate your recommendation and are always here if you need anything."
Alok Lokesh
March 14, 2025
"The team is very responsive and always assisting on time."
"Thank you for the kind words, Alok. We are so glad our team was able to assist you. Thank you for choosing our agency."
MT Photography
March 11, 2025
"I had a problem that needed immediate attention and I called the office and the staff (Claudia C) was able to get what I needed changed and sent to me. I'm always on the go with my business and need an Insurance agent who is able to accommodate my needs. This is definitely the agency."
"Thank you for the kind words. We are so happy our team was able to assist you with all of your insurance needs. Thank you for choosing our agency."
David Altfeld
March 10, 2025
"My account was transferred to Garrett years ago when my agent retired. I was a little worried at first, but Garrett and his team have always been very helpful with any request I have."
"Thank you for the kind words, David. We are so happy we were able to help with all of your insurance needs. Thank you for choosing our agency."